

Credit: Tom Sofield/LevittownNow.com
A Levittown man was found guilty Friday on a number of charges tied to a road-rage incident and armed confrontation with a motorist and police last year.
Advertisements
A jury at the Justice Center found John Thomas Mathis, 45, guilty of prohibited possession of a firearm, firearms not to be carried without a license, terroristic threats, possession of a weapon, possession of an instrument of crime, simple assault, recklessly endangering another person, evading arrest or detention on foot, and several traffic offenses after a trial that began Tuesday before Senior Judge Thomas C. Branca.

Credit: Bristol Township police
The senior judge deferred sentencing until January.
During the trial, Deputy District Attorneys Megan Stricker and Catherine Pirolli presented testimony from the victims, Bensalem Township police officers and district attorney’s office detectives about the events of Aug. 2, 2025.
Advertisements
According to testimony, a motorist called 911 around 5:43 p.m. to report that a man, who was later identified as Mathis, riding a black Kawasaki Ninja motorcycle was brandishing a handgun along a 2.5-mile stretch of northbound Bristol Pike in Bensalem Township. The victim testified that Mathis pointed the weapon at their face and threatened to shoot and rob them before the victim drove away to call for help.
A responding Bensalem Township police officer placed his patrol vehicle between the victim’s car and Mathisโ motorcycle.
According to police testimony, Mathis fled on foot with a firearm in his right hand and ignored commands to stop and show his hands, prompting the officer to fire his weapon and shoot Mathis.
Advertisements
Police said they recovered an unregistered black 9 mm pistol at the scene.
Due to prior felony convictions, Mathis is legally barred from possessing firearms.
In closing arguments Friday, Stricker detailed the road-rage incident and what she described as a mounting string of dangerous decisions Mathis made during the encounter.
Advertisements
Mathis is already serving a state prison sentence of 9 1/2 to 19 years, followed by three years of probation, from a separate conviction for aggravated assault by vehicle while driving under the influence.
At the time of the August 2025 confrontation, Mathis had several open criminal cases pending across Bucks County, including the Bristol Township DUI assault case, a separate Bristol Township road-rage incident, receiving stolen property cases in Bristol Borough and Lower Southampton Township, and a fleeing incident in Middletown Township.
Those cases have since been resolved, prosecutors said.
Advertisements
The district attorney’s office stated that about an hour before the Bensalem Township incident that led to him being shot, Mathis allegedly robbed a Metro by T-Mobile store in Philadelphia using a black semi-automatic handgun before fleeing north into Bucks County.
Charges in that case remain pending in Philadelphia.
Bucks County District Attorney Joe Khan commended the responding officer and credited Stricker and Pirolli, two veteran prosecutors who returned to the office earlier this year, for securing the conviction.
โBringing back seasoned, battle-tested prosecutors like Megan and Cate has bolstered our ability to hold violent repeat offenders accountable,โ Khan said. โThis verdict is a testament to their courtroom expertise and the bravery of the Bensalem police officer who stepped directly into harm’s way to stop an armed suspect. My office will always stand shoulder-to-shoulder with the dedicated men and women in uniform who keep Bucks County safe.โ
Advertisements
The district attorney noted the work of county detectives William Mooney and Kelcy Pitts, along with Deputy District Attorney Megan Hunsicker.


